WORK


CLOUDS


TUNNELS


INFO
 

 

 
      
NATHANIEL ROBINSON                                                                                                                                                                       NATHANIELROB@GMAIL.COM
 
Think of a cloud — just one cloud, and around it a  clear blue sky. Seen from the ground, 
the cloud may seem to have a  sharp boundary. Not so. The cloud is a swarm of water droplets. 
At the  outskirts of the cloud, the density of the droplets falls off.  Eventually they are 
so few and far between that we may hesitate to say  that the outlying droplets are still 
part of the cloud at all; perhaps we might better say only that they are near the cloud. 
But the transition is gradual. Many surfaces are equally good candidates to be  
the boundary of the cloud. Therefore many aggregates of droplets, some more inclusive and 
some less inclusive (and some inclusive in different  ways than others), are equally good 
candidates to be the cloud. Since  they have equal claim, how can we say that the cloud is 
one of these  aggregates rather than another? But if all of them count as clouds,  then we 
have many clouds rather than one. And if none of them count,  each one being ruled out 
because of the competition from the others,  then we have no cloud. How is it, then, that 
we have just one cloud?  And yet we do. (Lewis 1993: 164)

as cited at
http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/problem-of-many

clouds coming soon...